5 Common Mistakes Your Retirement Plan Provider Might Be Making (And How We Can Do Better)

Choosing the right retirement plan provider is crucial for both your clients’ success and regulatory compliance. While many providers market themselves as a “one-stop shop,” their approach can often lead to slower response times, miscommunications, and unnecessary risks. At October Three Consulting, we take a different, more efficient approach to retirement plan service. Let’s explore five common mistakes your retirement plan provider might be making and why October Three is a better choice.

1. The “Single Point of Contact” Who Isn’t Truly an Expert …

The Problem: Many providers offer a “single point of contact” (typically a CRM or client relationship manager) for both 401(k) and cash balance (CB) plans. However, these CRMs often lack specialized knowledge of either plan — especially when it comes to complex cash balance plans. While their role is to field questions, they may not always provide the most accurate or timely information, leading to delays and confusion.

How We Do It Differently: At October Three, we cut out the CRM middleman. Our consultants are cash balance professionals who work directly with your clients. This means more precise, faster responses and clearer communication. No confusion or unnecessary steps or delays.

2. Outsourcing Actuarial Work Without Direct Client Interaction

The Problem: Some third-party administrators (TPAs) outsource their actuarial services - especially when managing 401(k) plans with attached cash balance plans. This can lead to a lack of direct communication between clients and their actuaries, creating more opportunities for mistakes and miscommunication. Clients may not fully understand the process or timelines because the outsourced actuaries aren’t directly engaged.

How We Do It Differently: At October Three, all our actuaries are in-house and work directly with your clients. We believe in transparent, direct communication, ensuring your clients always know where they stand — avoiding unnecessary intermediaries or confusion.

3. Failing to Understand the Importance of Timing & Deadlines

The Problem: Without in-depth knowledge of both 401(k) and cash balance plans, some CRMs fail to grasp the urgency of key deadlines. For example, cash balance plans have different and distinct funding requirements from 401(k)s that can be missed if not handled properly. A small delay can lead to significant consequences, such as plan disqualification or hefty fines.

How We Do It Differently: Our team understands the critical importance of timing and deadlines. Whether it’s funding considerations, filing required forms or addressing specific plan needs, we ensure all deadlines are met, and compliance is maintained. We proactively inform clients about upcoming milestones, so they’re always in the loop.

4. Misapplying Concepts Across Different Plan Types

The Problem: When a single CRM manages both 401(k) and CB plans, there's a real risk of incorrectly applying 401(k)-specific concepts to a cash balance plan. This can lead to costly compliance errors that potentially jeopardize the plan’s status.

How We Do It Differently: Our experts focus exclusively on cash balance plans. By specializing in one plan type, we ensure that every decision is based on the most up-to-date, relevant knowledge. This reduces the risk of applying incorrect or outdated practices, keeping your clients’ plans compliant and running smoothly.

5. Poor Communication & Slow Response Times

The Problem: Bundled retirement plan providers place a non-expert as the lead communicator, which leads to delays and frustration. Clients may need to follow up repeatedly, and by the time they receive answers, they’ve lost valuable time. The back-and-forth can be frustrating and lead to a negative perception of the provider’s service capabilities.

How We Do It Differently: At October Three, we value speed and accuracy. By cutting out unnecessary intermediaries, we provide direct access to experts who understand your clients' plans inside and out. This means quicker responses, fewer misunderstandings, and a more efficient, accountable streamlined experience for your clients.

Conclusion: The October Three Difference

At October Three Consulting, we prioritize efficiency, expertise, and clear communication. We eliminate the need for ‘one size fits all’ CRMs, ensuring your clients work directly with CB specialists actually servicing their cash balance plan.

In a world where shortcuts and delays are too common, we pride ourselves on getting it right — every time. If you’re ready to partner with a provider who values your clients’ success as much as you do, reach out to us at October Three. We’re here to help you and your clients navigate retirement planning with confidence and ease.