Loading article...
Choosing the right administrator is one of the most important decisions you'll make when implementing a Cash Balance plan. Unlike a standard 401(k), a Cash Balance plan requires annual actuarial certification and a mandatory annual funding obligation, in addition to standard participant account administration and regulatory compliance.
The administrative right partner can help ensure the plan runs smoothly, while the wrong one can create administrative issues or, worse, affect the plan’s performance.
In this article, we explore the additional administrative demands required of Cash Balance plans and cover common questions employers can ask prospective partners to help find the right partner.
Cash Balance plan administration is unique because it combines the participant-level recordkeeping features of a Defined Contribution plan, like a 401(k), with the actuarial funding and compliance requirements of a Defined Benefit plan.
Unlike a traditional Defined Benefit plan, where participants typically receive a promised retirement benefit calculated under a formula, a Cash Balance plan maintains a participant-level account balance that is updated annually with pay credits and interest credits.
Although the participant experience resembles a Defined Contribution plan, with an account balance similar to a 401(k), a Cash Balance plan remains a Defined Benefit plan under the law. The employer retains investment risk and must satisfy annual actuarial funding requirements, as well as ongoing compliance and regulatory requirements.
Because Cash Balance plans combine participant account administration with Defined Benefit funding and actuarial requirements, employers often benefit from working with an administrator that specializes in Cash Balance plans rather than a standard Defined Contribution plan administrator.
Beyond specialization in Cash Balance plans, consider the following factors when comparing administrative partners.
Because Cash Balance plans require the support of an actuary for annual actuarial valuations and funding calculations, it's valuable to work with an administrator that has actuarial expertise built into its service model. An integrated approach helps ensure participant records, funding calculations, and regulatory filings remain aligned while reducing delays and miscommunication between service providers.
It also gives employers and advisors access to expert guidance on any contribution requirements, plan amendments, or other decisions that can affect the plan's funding and long-term success.
Are actuarial services provided in-house or outsourced?
Who prepares the annual valuation and funding recommendations?
How are administrative and actuarial teams coordinated throughout the year?
Will we receive proactive guidance on contribution strategies and plan changes?
Who can we contact with actuarial or funding questions?
With the right partner, your administrator’s tech stack can change how a Cash Balance plan is administered. As a baseline, look for an administrator that provides participant self-service and simplifies day-to-day workflows.
You will also want to ensure the provider does not use daily valuation systems created for Defined Contribution plans, as doing so to value a Market-Based Cash Balance plan can have serious legal implications, including plan disqualification and/or participant litigation. A few reasons why include:
Defined Benefit plans must be able to identify a separate asset and liability: Defined Contribution valuation systems define the plan benefit as equal to the assets held by the plan for the participant. Hence, the assets and liabilities are the same. A Defined Benefit plan must have an identifiable plan benefit liability separate from the underlying asset.
Defined Benefit plans must credit earnings precisely as described in the plan document: Defined Contribution systems credit earnings based on contributions and investment gains and losses. However, the plan document must govern the development of the plan liability in a Defined Benefit plan.
Fiduciary risk is high if using a Defined Contribution system to administer a Defined Benefit plan: Sponsors could breach their fiduciary duty if they select a service provider that cannot correctly administer the pension plan.
Some administrators like October Three offer daily administration platforms specifically designed for Defined Benefit plans, which continuously reconcile participant benefits and plan assets, giving employers and advisors greater visibility into funding status and reducing the risk of surprises at year-end.
Is the administrator relying on a standard 401(k)/Defined Contribution platform to service the Cash Balance plan, and do they have integrated Defined Benefit actuarial software to ensure full IRS and ERISA compliance?
What online tools are available for employers and participants?
Can sponsors access reports and plan documents through an online portal?
How are participant balances and plan information updated throughout the year?
Do you offer advanced administration tools, such as daily reconciliation or continuous benefit tracking?
What reporting is included as part of your standard service?
Cash Balance plans often involve ongoing collaboration among employers, financial advisors, CPAs, and actuaries. A responsive administrator who communicates clearly and proactively can make the administration process significantly smoother and help keep the plan on track.
Will we have a dedicated relationship manager or service team?
What is your typical response time for client questions?
How do you coordinate with our financial advisor, CPA, and investment advisor?
How are participant questions and distribution requests handled?
How often will we review the plan and funding status together?
Some providers administer Cash Balance plans as one of many offerings, while others specialize almost exclusively in Defined Benefit and Cash Balance plans. Organizations with a specialized focus may offer deeper technical expertise and greater familiarity with complex plan designs.
If your Cash Balance plan will be paired with a 401(k) or profit-sharing plan, as most are, it is vital to choose an administrator with deep expertise in combined Defined Benefit/Defined Contribution nondiscrimination testing, also referred to as cross-testing. Proper cross-testing optimization directly impacts your plan design, ensuring you maximize owner tax deductions while maintaining cost-effective employee benefits.
Once you’ve selected a partner to administer your Cash Balance plan, you’ll want to familiarize yourself with the process of implementation. Our article, The Complete Guide to Implementing a Cash Balance Plan, can help with this process.
Or, if you’d prefer to get started with the process now, our team can help. Click below to schedule time to meet with one of our team members and learn more about how a Cash Balance plan could help your organization.