More than $10 trillion is held in 401(k) plans across the United States, representing decades of progress in helping American workers save for retirement. Automatic enrollment, contribution increases, default investment strategies, and better technology have made it easier for employees to participate and build retirement assets.
But as retirement savings have grown, an important question has emerged: Are 401(k) plans just tax-advantaged savings plans, and if so, how do we bridge the gap between those savings and the retirement income security that American workers actually need?
For employers, this question calls for a broader look at what their retirement benefits are designed to accomplish. A plan that helps employees accumulate assets is valuable. But a truly effective retirement strategy should also help them translate those assets into reliable income throughout retirement.
A recent Wall Street Journal article examined what it described as a selective revival of pensions among U.S. employers. Companies including IBM, JBS Foods, Northwell Health, and PECO have introduced or reopened pension plans, driven by factors including employee retention, labor negotiations, and changing pension economics.
These developments suggest that employers are reconsidering not just which retirement benefits they offer, but what they expect those benefits to deliver. As workforce needs evolve and employees place greater importance on retirement security, organizations are exploring whether their existing plans adequately address the full retirement journey.
In looking at alternatives, they find that certain modern pension designs offer better solutions to their needs, with the Wall Street Journal highlighting how Cash Balance designs deliver pension benefits without some of the financial uncertainty employers associate with traditional pensions.
Most 401(k)-inspired retirement plan scorecards focus on whether employees are saving adequately. Certainly, saving is a good thing. But it doesn't tell the whole story.
Consider two core questions:
Can employees build enough wealth to retire
Can they convert those savings into income that will last a lifetime?
The second question presents a challenge that traditional 401(k) plans generally aren't designed to solve on their own. This is the accumulation-versus-decumulation challenge. While the retirement industry has made significant progress helping employees build wealth, the responsibility for converting that wealth into sustainable lifetime income largely remains with individuals.
A more comprehensive retirement strategy should help employees save more and make their savings last. 401(k)s and other Defined Contribution-only strategies often fail in both categories.
For many employers, the decision to move away from traditional defined benefit pensions was driven by concerns about unpredictable funding requirements, investment risk, and long-term financial commitments.
Today's market-based pension designs offer a different model. Rather than relying on the traditional final-average-pay structure, these plans can use market-linked investment returns and benefit formulas designed to provide greater predictability for plan sponsors.
As the Wall Street Journal noted, these developments have helped renew interest in pension benefits by changing some of the economic considerations that historically made employers hesitant.
Employers don't necessarily have to choose between the flexibility of a defined contribution plan and the retirement income advantages of a defined benefit plan. Modern designs create opportunities to bring the strengths of both together.
At October Three, we believe the next evolution in retirement planning is a comprehensive market-based strategy that combines defined contribution plans with market-based defined benefit plans.
In this approach, each plan serves a complementary purpose. The 401(k) continues to act as an important savings and investment vehicle while being paired with a Market-Based Pension that addresses needs that are much harder to solve through a Defined Contribution plan alone.
Rather than expecting one plan to accomplish everything, employers can structure their retirement benefits to address different employee needs throughout their working years and into retirement.
This approach also creates an opportunity to rethink how retirement benefits are evaluated. Instead of focusing exclusively on participation and accumulated assets, employers can consider how effectively their combined plans support retirement readiness, income security, and employees' long-term financial well-being.
The evolution of retirement benefits doesn't diminish what defined contribution plans have accomplished. They've expanded access to workplace retirement savings and given millions of Americans a way to build assets for the future.
But helping employees save for retirement and helping them succeed in retirement are two different objectives.
Employers aren’t going to return to the pensions of the past. The future of employer-sponsored retirement doesn't have to be exclusively defined benefit or defined contribution. By thoughtfully combining both, organizations can move beyond simply helping employees accumulate retirement savings and toward a more complete goal: helping them achieve a secure retirement.