The Wall Street Journal recently reported that a small but growing number of employers are introducing or reopening pension benefits. Their reasons range from improving the recruitment of new employees, retaining key workers, or resolving labor negotiations to financial considerations. Many employees view the pension as the ideal retirement benefit. One PECO employee put the value proposition plainly:
“Having a pension is a big motivator for staying with the company.”
For some organizations, the initial reaction to the idea of a pension revival may be concern. Traditional pension designs were often associated in the past with increased risk and volatility, and many employers have spent years improving their Defined Contribution plans.
But employers don't need to return to the plans of the past to meet the needs of today. Just as 401(k)s have changed over the years, pensions have evolved, and selecting the right plan comes down to understanding the benefits of each and how well they deliver what employees are ultimately after.
Employees don't value a plan because of its features or name; they value what it will do for them. Will they have enough to retire? Will their money last? How is their employer helping them secure their financial futures?
Traditional pensions addressed those questions in a very one-sided way that, to its credit, was simple to understand. Work long enough, and there will be income waiting for you in retirement. If, on the other hand, you didn’t work long enough for one employer, then things got messier, and from the employer’s perspective, they were anything but simple.
The DC Plan answered a different question, giving employees a savings opportunity instead of an outcome. The structure provided by DCs brought important advantages, including portability, individual control, and transparency. But it also shifted the responsibility for producing a successful retirement onto the employee.
The metrics by which success was measured changed. A plan would be deemed a success if it had excellent participation, low fees, and strong investment options. But an excellent DC plan could still leave employees uncertain about whether they have enough to retire or how to make their assets last. That doesn't make the DC Plan unsuccessful. It just means the job is unfinished.
The renewed interest in pensions highlighted by the Wall Street Journal suggests that employers are beginning to look beyond the DC success metrics of participation and fees, toward a broader definition of employee value.
That is particularly apparent where competition for workers or labor negotiations are involved. The article points to pension developments at PECO, JBS Foods, Northwell Health, Delta and Southwest, among others.
The common thread is value. A retirement benefit can become a powerful workforce tool when employees understand that it meaningfully improves their future, leading to a different way of thinking about retirement benefits.
Rather than asking whether employees appreciate the plan features, ask whether the plan produces outcomes employees care about.
Can it help them build more financial security?
Can it help those assets last?
Is it valuable enough that employees recognize it as part of the reason to work here?
Shifting benefits don’t require abandoning the DC Plan. At October Three, we believe that a modern retirement strategy often combines a Defined Contribution Plan with a Market-Based Pension Plan.
The DC plan continues to provide familiar employee savings and investment opportunities, while the Market-Based Pension plan adds another dimension - a retirement engine that creates additional income deferral opportunities and delivers efficient and effective lifetime income. Together, they offer a truly different employer benefit.
Instead of forcing employees into the pension models of the past or the DC models of today, employers can combine elements of both to create the retirement plan of the future. A good savings plan helps employees build an account, but a good retirement plan helps them build a future.